How Old Is Islam vs Christianity vs Judaism? A Complete Comparison

0

AI-assisted, scholar-reviewed. Comparative answer with citations across all three traditions.

TL;DR: Judaism is the oldest of the three Abrahamic faiths, tracing its roots to Abraham and Moses thousands of years BCE. Christianity emerged roughly 2,000 years ago centered on Jesus of Nazareth Luke 2:42. Islam was founded in the 7th century CE by the Prophet Muhammad, making it the youngest of the three — yet all three traditions claim Abraham as a foundational patriarch Genesis 17:24. Their biggest disagreement is who represents the final or fullest revelation of God's will.

Judaism

And Abraham was ninety years old and nine, when he was circumcised in the flesh of his foreskin. — Genesis 17:24

Judaism is widely considered the oldest of the three Abrahamic religions, with origins scholars trace back roughly 3,500 to 4,000 years. Its foundational narratives center on the patriarchs — Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob — and the covenant God established with them Genesis 17:24. Abraham's circumcision at age ninety-nine is recorded as a defining moment of that covenant Genesis 17:24, and his son Isaac's birth marks the continuation of the promised lineage Genesis 21:5.

The formal giving of the Torah at Sinai, mediated by Moses, is another landmark moment. Moses was eighty years old when he stood before Pharaoh Exodus 7:7, suggesting a long period of formation before Israel's laws were codified. Rabbinic tradition dates the Torah's revelation to approximately 1312 BCE, though scholarly estimates vary. Judaism's longevity makes it the parent tradition from which both Christianity and Islam drew heavily.

Judaism does not recognize Jesus as the Messiah nor Muhammad as a prophet, viewing its own covenant as complete and ongoing. The Hebrew scriptures — the Tanakh — remain the sole canonical revelation, and Jewish communities have maintained continuous practice for millennia despite diaspora and persecution.

Christianity

And when he was twelve years old, they went up to Jerusalem after the custom of the feast. — Luke 2:42

Christianity is approximately 2,000 years old, emerging in the 1st century CE in Roman-occupied Judea. It centers on the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus of Nazareth, whom Christians believe to be the Son of God and the promised Messiah of the Hebrew scriptures. The Gospels record details of Jesus's early life — including that at twelve years old he was already engaging teachers in Jerusalem Luke 2:42 — underscoring his identity as rooted in Jewish tradition.

Christianity grew out of Second Temple Judaism and initially spread among Jewish communities before expanding rapidly into the Gentile world through the missionary work of the Apostle Paul and others. By the 4th century CE, it had become the official religion of the Roman Empire. Today it's the world's largest religion, with over 2.4 billion adherents across Catholic, Protestant, and Orthodox branches.

Christians trace their spiritual ancestry back to Abraham Genesis 17:24, whom Paul calls the 'father of all who believe' (Romans 4:11). This shared Abrahamic heritage connects Christianity to both Judaism and Islam, though Christians uniquely affirm Jesus as the definitive and final Word of God incarnate.

Islam

And Ishmael his son was thirteen years old, when he was circumcised in the flesh of his foreskin. — Genesis 17:25

Islam is the youngest of the three Abrahamic faiths, founded in the 7th century CE — approximately 610 CE — when the Prophet Muhammad received his first revelation in a cave near Mecca. Islam is therefore roughly 1,400 years old, making it about 600 years younger than Christianity and over 2,000 years younger than the earliest forms of Judaism. Despite being the youngest, Islam claims to be the restoration of the original, uncorrupted faith of Abraham Genesis 17:24.

The Quran explicitly honors Abraham, Isaac, and Ishmael as prophets and models of submission to God. Ishmael — born when Abram was eighty-six years old Genesis 16:16 — holds a particularly important place in Islamic tradition, as Muslims trace Muhammad's lineage and the Ka'bah in Mecca back to Ishmael and Abraham. Ishmael's circumcision at thirteen Genesis 17:25 is also noted in Islamic tradition as a sign of covenant faithfulness.

Islam spread with extraordinary speed across Arabia, the Middle East, North Africa, and beyond within just a century of Muhammad's death in 632 CE. Today it's the world's second-largest religion with roughly 1.9 billion followers. Muslims believe the Quran is God's final, perfectly preserved revelation, superseding earlier scriptures they view as having been altered over time.

Where they agree

  • Shared Abrahamic Patriarch: All three religions trace their spiritual lineage to Abraham, whose covenant with God — marked by circumcision at age ninety-nine — is foundational to each tradition Genesis 17:24.
  • Monotheism: Judaism, Christianity, and Islam all affirm the existence of one God who acts in human history and calls people into covenant relationship.
  • Moses as a Prophet: All three traditions honor Moses, who was eighty years old when he confronted Pharaoh as God's messenger Exodus 7:7, as a major figure of divine revelation.
  • Ishmael and Isaac: All three acknowledge both Ishmael Genesis 16:16 and Isaac Genesis 21:5 as sons of Abraham, though they differ on which son carries the primary covenantal significance.
  • Scripture and Revelation: Each religion holds that God communicates with humanity through revealed texts and chosen prophets or messengers.

Where they disagree

IssueJudaismChristianityIslam
Age / Founding~3,500–4,000 years old; origins with Abraham Genesis 17:24 and Moses Exodus 7:7~2,000 years old; founded in 1st century CE around Jesus Luke 2:42~1,400 years old; founded 610 CE with Muhammad's first revelation
Final RevelationThe Torah and Tanakh are complete; no further revelation neededJesus is the living Word of God — the fullest and final revelationThe Quran is God's final, uncorrupted revelation, superseding prior scriptures
Identity of the MessiahThe Messiah has not yet comeJesus of Nazareth is the Messiah and Son of God Luke 2:42Jesus was a prophet, not divine; Muhammad is the final prophet
Covenantal Heir of AbrahamIsaac Genesis 21:5 and the Jewish people carry the primary covenantSpiritual heirs are all believers in Christ, tracing back to Abraham Genesis 17:24Ishmael Genesis 16:16 Genesis 17:25 is honored as ancestor of the Arab people and Muhammad
Scripture CanonTanakh (Hebrew Bible) onlyOld and New TestamentsQuran as primary; Torah and Gospels acknowledged but seen as corrupted

Key takeaways

  • Judaism is the oldest Abrahamic faith at roughly 3,500–4,000 years old, rooted in the covenants with Abraham Genesis 17:24 and Moses Exodus 7:7.
  • Christianity is approximately 2,000 years old, emerging in the 1st century CE around Jesus of Nazareth Luke 2:42.
  • Islam is the youngest at roughly 1,400 years old, founded in 610 CE — about 600 years after Christianity.
  • All three religions claim Abraham as a foundational patriarch Genesis 17:24, but differ on who carries the primary covenantal line — Isaac Genesis 21:5 or Ishmael Genesis 16:16 Genesis 17:25.
  • Despite their age differences, Islam, Christianity, and Judaism share core commitments to monotheism, revealed scripture, and prophetic tradition.

FAQs

How old is Islam compared to Christianity?
Islam is approximately 1,400 years old, founded around 610 CE, while Christianity is roughly 2,000 years old, emerging in the 1st century CE. That makes Christianity about 600 years older than Islam. Both religions, however, trace their roots back to Abraham Genesis 17:24, who lived thousands of years earlier, and both honor Moses Exodus 7:7 as a major prophet.
Which is the oldest religion — Judaism, Christianity, or Islam?
Judaism is the oldest of the three, with roots stretching back roughly 3,500–4,000 years to the patriarchal period. Abraham's covenant with God Genesis 17:24 and Moses's leadership of Israel Exodus 7:7 are its earliest foundational events. Christianity came next (~2,000 years ago) Luke 2:42, and Islam is the youngest (~1,400 years ago).
Do Islam and Christianity share any common origins?
Yes — both are Abrahamic faiths that trace their spiritual ancestry to Abraham Genesis 17:24 and honor Moses as a prophet Exodus 7:7. Christianity grew directly out of Judaism in the 1st century CE, and Islam emerged in the 7th century CE also claiming the Abrahamic lineage, particularly through Ishmael, who was born when Abram was eighty-six Genesis 16:16.
Why does Islam consider Ishmael important?
Islamic tradition traces the Prophet Muhammad's lineage and the founding of the Ka'bah in Mecca back to Ishmael and Abraham. Genesis records that Ishmael was born when Abram was eighty-six years old Genesis 16:16 and was circumcised at thirteen Genesis 17:25, which Islamic tradition cites as evidence of his covenant faithfulness and prophetic heritage.
At what age did Jesus first appear in scripture as teaching?
The Gospel of Luke records that Jesus was twelve years old when his parents found him in the Jerusalem temple, engaging teachers during the Passover feast Luke 2:42. This is the only canonical account of Jesus's childhood beyond his infancy narratives.

0 Community answers

No community answers yet. Share what you've read or learned — with sources.

Your answer

Log in or sign up to post a community answer.

Discussion

No comments yet. Be the first to share an interpretation, source, or counter-argument.

Add a comment

Comments are moderated before publishing. Cite a source when you can — that's what makes this site useful.

0/2000