Who Created God? What Judaism, Christianity, and Islam Teach

0

AI-generated answers. Same retrieval, same compare prompt, multiple models — compare across tabs. Every citation links to a primary source.

Generated by Claude Sonnet 4.6 (Anthropic) · 2026-05-14 · same retrieved passages, same compare-format prompt

TL;DR: All three Abrahamic faiths share a foundational conviction: God was not created by anyone or anything. Judaism, Christianity, and Islam each affirm that God is eternal, self-existent, and the uncaused cause of all that exists. The question itself, while philosophically rich, is considered by theologians across all three traditions to rest on a category error — God, by definition, transcends the created order and therefore has no origin. Thinkers like Maimonides (12th c.), Thomas Aquinas (13th c.), and Al-Ghazali (11th c.) each argued this from within their own traditions.

Judaism

In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth. — Genesis 1:1 (KJV) Genesis 1:1

Judaism's answer is unambiguous: no one created God. God is the uncreated Creator, the ultimate source of all existence. The very first verse of the Torah establishes this posture — God acts; God is not acted upon Genesis 1:1. The Hebrew word bara (created) is used exclusively of divine creative activity in the Hebrew Bible, never of anything done to God.

Isaiah reinforces this with striking directness. God declares through the prophet that He formed the earth, established it, and created it purposefully — and then identifies Himself as the LORD with no rival and no predecessor Isaiah 45:18. The rhetorical question in Isaiah 44 — who has formed a god? — is asked mockingly of idol-makers, implying that a truly formed or manufactured deity is no deity at all Isaiah 44:10.

Maimonides, in his Mishneh Torah (1180 CE), articulated what Jewish philosophy calls aseity — God's absolute self-existence. God doesn't derive existence from anything external. He is the Necessary Existent. This became a cornerstone of medieval Jewish rationalism and remains normative across Orthodox, Conservative, and Reform Judaism today. The question 'who created God?' is therefore not evasive but genuinely inapplicable: the category of 'creation' simply doesn't extend to the Creator.

Christianity

God that made the world and all things therein, seeing that he is Lord of heaven and earth, dwelleth not in temples made with hands. — Acts 17:24 (KJV) Acts 17:24

Christianity inherits the Jewish conviction of God's eternity and adds its own theological elaboration. The Apostle Paul, preaching in Athens (c. 50 CE), declared that God made the entire world and everything in it — and that this same God, as Lord of heaven and earth, is not confined to human-made structures Acts 17:24. The implication is clear: the Maker of all things cannot Himself be made.

Genesis opens the Christian Old Testament with the same foundational claim — God creates; He is not created Genesis 1:1. Isaiah 42:5 extends this, describing God as the one who created the heavens and stretched them out, giving breath and spirit to all living things Isaiah 42:5. These texts form the scriptural backbone of the Christian doctrine of creatio ex nihilo — creation out of nothing — which logically requires an uncreated Creator.

Thomas Aquinas, in his Summa Theologica (1265–1274 CE), formalized the cosmological argument: everything that exists has a cause, but an infinite regress of causes is impossible, so there must be a First Cause that is itself uncaused. He called this God. Crucially, God doesn't belong to the category of 'things that exist contingently' — He exists necessarily. Modern Christian philosopher Alvin Plantinga has made similar arguments in the 20th century. Disagreement exists on the fringes — process theologians like Alfred North Whitehead suggested God and the world are mutually dependent — but this remains a minority view rejected by most Catholic, Protestant, and Orthodox theologians.

Islam

Say: He is Allah, the One and Only; Allah, the Eternal, Absolute; He begetteth not, nor is He begotten; And there is none like unto Him. — Quran 112:1–4 (Yusuf Ali)

Islam addresses this question with perhaps its most concentrated theological statement anywhere in the Quran: Surah Al-Ikhlas (112), a four-verse chapter considered equal in weight to a third of the entire Quran according to hadith tradition. It declares that God — Allah — is Al-Samad, the Eternal Absolute, who neither begets nor was begotten, and who has no equal. The Arabic term Al-Samad carries the meaning of one who depends on nothing and on whom everything depends.

Al-Ghazali (1058–1111 CE), in his Ihya Ulum al-Din, argued that God's existence is wajib al-wujud — necessarily existent — meaning it's logically impossible for God not to exist, and equally impossible for God to have been caused or created. Ibn Sina (Avicenna, 980–1037 CE) developed this into a full philosophical proof that influenced both Islamic and Christian scholasticism.

Islamic theology (kalam) is emphatic: God has no beginning, no end, and no origin. The question 'who created God?' is considered a confusion of categories — like asking what is north of the North Pole. God is not a contingent being within the universe; He is the ground of all being. This is considered one of the clearest points of tawhid (divine unity and uniqueness) in Islamic thought.

Where they agree

All three Abrahamic faiths converge on a striking consensus here. God is uncreated, eternal, and self-existent. None of the traditions entertains the idea that God had an origin or a maker. Each tradition affirms that God is the cause of all things, not an effect of anything Acts 17:24 Genesis 1:1 Isaiah 45:18. The philosophical concept of divine aseity — God's absolute independence of existence — is shared across Maimonides, Aquinas, and Al-Ghazali, even though they wrote in different centuries and languages. All three also agree that Isaiah's portrait of God as the one who 'created the heavens' and 'formed the earth' places God categorically outside the created order Isaiah 42:5.

Where they disagree

DimensionJudaismChristianityIslam
How God's eternity is expressedPrimarily through Torah narrative and Maimonidean philosophy; God's name YHWH implies eternal self-existenceThrough both scripture and Trinitarian theology; the eternal Word (Logos) is part of the GodheadThrough the Quranic concept of Al-Samad and kalam theology; most direct and concise formulation
Nature of GodStrictly unitary; no persons or hypostasesTriune — Father, Son, Holy Spirit — yet one God; the eternal nature applies to all three personsStrictly unitary (tawhid); the Trinity is explicitly rejected as incompatible with divine unity
Primary theological methodRabbinic commentary and medieval rationalism (Maimonides)Systematic theology and natural theology (Aquinas, Plantinga)Quranic declaration and kalam philosophy (Al-Ghazali, Ibn Sina)
Minority dissentVirtually none on this specific pointProcess theology (Whitehead) suggests mutual God-world dependence — rejected by mainstreamVirtually none; tawhid makes this non-negotiable

Key takeaways

  • All three Abrahamic faiths — Judaism, Christianity, and Islam — unanimously teach that God was not created by anyone or anything.
  • The question 'who created God?' is considered a category error by theologians like Maimonides, Aquinas, and Al-Ghazali: God is the uncaused First Cause, not a contingent being.
  • Genesis 1:1 and Isaiah 45:18 establish God as the uncreated Creator in the Hebrew Bible, foundational to both Jewish and Christian theology.
  • Islam's Surah Al-Ikhlas (Quran 112) offers the most concise scriptural declaration: God is eternal, was not begotten, and has no equal.
  • While all three traditions agree God is uncreated, they differ on God's inner nature — Judaism and Islam insist on strict unity, while Christianity affirms a Triune God whose eternal nature applies to all three persons.

FAQs

Is 'who created God?' considered a valid question in theology?
Most theologians across all three traditions say it's a category error. God, by definition, is the uncaused First Cause — asking who created God is like asking what existed before time, since God created time itself Genesis 1:1. Aquinas and Al-Ghazali both addressed this directly in their philosophical works.
What does the Bible say about God's origin?
The Bible doesn't address God's 'origin' because it assumes He has none. Genesis 1:1 opens with God already acting as Creator Genesis 1:1, and Isaiah 45:18 has God declaring 'I am the LORD; and there is none else' — implying no predecessor or maker Isaiah 45:18. Acts 17:24 describes God as the maker of 'the world and all things therein' Acts 17:24, which logically excludes Him from being made.
Does Islam have a specific verse about God not being created?
Yes — Surah Al-Ikhlas (Quran 112) is the most direct statement. It declares God is Al-Samad (the Eternal Absolute), was not begotten, and has no equal. Islamic scholars like Ibn Sina (11th c.) built full philosophical proofs of God's necessary, uncreated existence on this foundation.
Did God create humans, according to these traditions?
Yes, all three affirm this. Genesis 1:27 states God created man in His own image Genesis 1:27, and Genesis 2:7 describes God forming man from dust and breathing life into him Genesis 2:7. Islam and Christianity both affirm this same creation narrative in their own theological frameworks.
What is the difference between God creating and being created?
Isaiah 44:10 mocks the idea of a 'formed god' — a deity that was made is, by that very fact, not truly God Isaiah 44:10. Isaiah 42:5 presents the true God as the one who created the heavens and gives breath to all living things Isaiah 42:5, placing Him entirely outside the category of created things. This distinction is foundational to all three Abrahamic faiths.

0 Community answers

No community answers yet. Share what you've read or learned — with sources.

Your answer

Log in or sign up to post a community answer.

Discussion

No comments yet. Be the first to share an interpretation, source, or counter-argument.

Add a comment

Comments are moderated before publishing. Cite a source when you can — that's what makes this site useful.

0/2000